Skip to main content

MATTISON'S CITY GRILLE HONORED AS A SARASOTA LEGACY BUSINESS

Mattison’s City Grille, a chef-owned local restaurant that opened its doors on December 8, 2002, has been officially recognized by the City of Sarasota as a Legacy Business – a special honor celebrating over two decades of service to the community. At a recent City Commission meeting, Chef Paul Mattison accepted a formal Legacy Business proclamation from Sarasota officials, marking a proud moment for the downtown restaurant’s nearly 23-year journey. This proclamation is part of the city’s new Legacy Business Program, which acknowledges long-standing businesses that have contributed to Sarasota’s growth and prosperity. For Mattison’s City Grille, being named a Legacy Business is a meaningful recognition of its history, resilience, and impact on the local community.

A Humbling Honor After 23 Years in Sarasota

Receiving the Legacy Business award was truly humbling for Chef Paul and the entire Mattison’s team. In his remarks at City Hall, Chef Paul expressed that it’s “an honor to be recognized” after so many years in business, noting that one rarely pauses to reflect on such milestones when caught up in day-to-day operations. This accolade gave us a moment to appreciate how far we’ve come. Mattison’s City Grille has weathered many ups and downs over the years – from economic shifts to the challenges of a global pandemic – and it hasn’t always been easy. “Everything’s changed a lot since the pandemic,” Chef Paul has said, explaining that we had to adapt and reinvent aspects of the business to overcome new difficulties. Running a restaurant has become more expensive and more challenging in recent times, and unfortunately many eateries have come and gone. Being recognized for persevering through these “crazy times” makes this honor even more special. It reassures us that all the hard work, creativity, and tenacity over the past 23 years have truly made a difference.

When Chef Paul stepped up to receive the proclamation, he thanked the City Commissioners for their support and took a moment to share his love for Sarasota. “It’s been a great 23 years. We love Sarasota, love the city,” he said with heartfelt gratitude. He also acknowledged the efforts of city leaders (past and present) who have worked with local businesses like ours over the years. The recognition felt very genuine and validating. “You get so busy in your day-to-day business, you don’t think about what you do or how long you’ve been doing it,” Chef Paul later reflected. “It was really a nice honor to be recognized like that.” After the ceremony, he humbly joked that he “should have prepared something” to say – there were so many people he wished to thank and so many memories to share. In truth, this award belongs to everyone who has been part of the Mattison’s City Grille story: our loyal guests, our dedicated staff, and the supportive Sarasota community that embraced us from the beginning.

From Sleepy Downtown to Vibrant Dining Destination

One of the reasons this Legacy Business honor is so meaningful is because of the dramatic transformation we’ve witnessed in downtown Sarasota since 2002. When Mattison’s City Grille first opened, downtown was a much quieter place – some might even say a bit “dark and sleepy” in the evenings. In fact, the corner of Lemon Avenue and Main Street (where our restaurant is located) looked very different back then. The site where Whole Foods stands today was once just a dirt parking lot, and the central bus station was a small glass shelter with a simple bench inside. Nightlife and outdoor dining in downtown Sarasota were not as common as they are now. Back then, many people thought opening a restaurant in that spot was a risky idea. Chef Paul recalls friends and colleagues asking if he was crazy to open a cafe in a part of town that “was not happening.” But he had a vision and faith that downtown Sarasota’s time was coming – and he wanted Mattison’s to be part of that renaissance.

Over the years, we’ve had a front-row seat (quite literally, from our patio!) to downtown’s revival. The City’s efforts to revitalize the area – like the beautiful Lemon Avenue streetscape project that replaced curbs with brick pavers – helped turn our street into a central gathering place for festivals, farmers markets, and events of all kinds. New businesses, residences, and cultural attractions started blossoming around us. Mattison’s City Grille was there in those early days, and we’re proud to have contributed to the energy that brought downtown Sarasota to life. Our concept of an upscale, European-style outdoor café with live music was somewhat unique in Sarasota at the time. We knew that in a city with gorgeous weather year-round, people would love to dine under the sun and stars. So we created a welcoming open-air space with plenty of patio seating and a lively atmosphere. Whether it’s a breezy al fresco lunch or an evening of dinner and dancing under twinkling lights, Mattison’s City Grille offers an experience that celebrates Sarasota’s climate and community spirit. We like to think this helped pave the way for the thriving outdoor dining scene Sarasota enjoys today. City officials even noted that Mattison’s became “a city fixture and a contributing asset to the vitality and prosperity of downtown” Sarasota – a testament to the role our little cafe played in the bigger picture of downtown’s growth.

A Community Legacy Built Together

While Mattison’s has expanded over the years – with fine dining at Mattison’s Forty-One, a location at the Riverwalk, a catering company, and more – City Grille has a special place in our hearts. It represents the casual, community-centered side of what we do. In fact, when many locals hear the name “Mattison’s,” it’s the image of friends gathered at the City Grille patio, enjoying food and live music, that often comes to mind. This restaurant has become a beloved community hub, a place where families celebrate birthdays, couples share date nights, and neighbors bump into each other at the weekly farmers market. It’s incredibly rewarding to see how a single idea – a friendly outdoor café in the heart of downtown – has grown into a tradition for Sarasota locals and a must-visit spot for visitors. Being officially proclaimed a Legacy Business by the city affirms that Mattison’s City Grille isn’t just our business – it’s part of Sarasota’s story.

Chef Paul often says that our success is only possible because of the people around us. On the day we received the award, he made sure to credit our entire team and the community. Vice Mayor Jen Ahearn-Koch, who spearheaded the Legacy Business Program (and incidentally was part of the Mattison’s family herself years ago), shared touching words at the ceremony about Mattison’s role in transforming downtown. Hearing a city leader – and former employee – talk about how Mattison’s helped spark the vibrant downtown we see today was incredibly moving for us. It was a proud and somewhat surreal moment to realize that what started as a dream in 2002 has indeed left a lasting imprint on the city.

Gratitude and Looking Ahead

This Legacy Business honor is not the finish line of our journey, but rather a joyful milestone that inspires us to continue our mission. We are deeply grateful – to the City of Sarasota for recognizing us, to the commissioners (especially Commissioner Jen) for their kind words and support, and most of all to our patrons and staff who truly earned this honor alongside us. Every customer who has dined with us under the palm trees, every musician who has played on our stage, and every staff member who has greeted guests with a smile – you have all shaped Mattison’s legacy. “Thank you” hardly covers it.

With our Legacy Business proclamation now proudly on display and a new decal soon gracing our window, we feel even more connected to the history and future of this city we call home. Chef Paul said it best at the ceremony: “We love being here and we look forward to many, many more years in the City of Sarasota”. As we celebrate this honor, we remain committed to serving our community with the same passion and quality that got us here. Mattison’s City Grille isn’t slowing down – we’re already looking ahead to the next 23 years of great food, great music, and great memories in downtown Sarasota. We invite you to come by and be a part of the celebration, whether it’s for a casual lunch, a festive dinner, or one of our signature live music nights. Here’s to the past, present, and future of Mattison’s City Grille – thank you, Sarasota, for making us a part of your story!